I think the night gardener wrote the letter. I think that because he wanted them to stay to scare them more, and to play tricks on them. I think that the part of the letter that says “keep out of trouble ( that means you kip!)” is fishy. I think that because Molly got the letter out of the hole from the “tree” and Kip was around “tree”, planting flowers and turning away for a second then seeing them dead, going to climb the tree but seeing the weapons, and digging a hole then having the roots of the “tree” try to take him. I think the “tree” doesn’t want him to be near it. That’s why I think that part is fishy.
I like when you said that was fishy I agree with you.
That was a very good observation and that is a very good reason when you said it said kip stay out of trouble while he was planting the flowers neer the tree.
i agree with u Isaiah that was a good observation!!!
I love how you put quotation marks around tree it makes it sound like a monster.!
I think the night man wrote the letter because They supposedly said to stay put no matter what and I don't think any parent would say it so mean.
When they said they were going to send another letter i thought how did they send the letter the first time if they did not know were Kip and Molly were living. Also i think that the night gardener has a backstory with their parents and he didn't have a good one. But that leads me too one more question how would the night man know their parents?
Their parents sent the letter into the sea thinking Kip and Molly might get this so they don't know where they live but the tree gave Molly the note.
I think an important part of the letter is when the “ PARENTS “ wrote stay where you are
because they might not be molly & kips parents. The nightman might of wrote the letter in their parents handwriting so the nightman can have them feel safe there. So they should be a little extra careful so they can feel safe! The nightman could be waiting for molly & kip so he can strike. What i’m trying to say is it might be the nightman and not their parents!!
I like yours Brendan because i like how you said "PARENTS" I agree its the nightman
The night gardener wrote the note.I know this because The night gardener was kinda was trying to trick on molly and Kip for having to look in the green door to see the money at the door.
The night gardener is trying to keep Molly and kip. I think that because He was writing that note for no reason was Molly and kip’s parents for years and years for a long time. The things that the Night Gardener could have said was I will keep you forever!!!!.
I agree with you because I think he is doing that too. But I also don't agree with you because you said " molly and kip for going threw the door.
I think the letter is from the night gardener, The Night man. I think it's from the night man because it said ‘’stay put” I mean why would their parents want them to stay put. Like if I was their mom i would tell them you can go to different places so you feel safe. I also think the night man did this because he probably wants them to feel scared and they want to leave because Kip and Molly saw him and he probably doesn't anyone to know that someone is walking around their house when they are sleeping.
Why do you think the night man would do that beside because they are scared? Great writing!!!!
kip’s parents for years and years for a long time. The things that the Night Gardener could have said was I will keep you forever!!!!.The night gardener wrote the note.I know this because The night gardener was kinda was trying to trick on molly and Kip for having to look in the green door to see the money at the door.
The night gardener is trying to keep Molly and kip. I think that because He was writing that note for no reason was Molly and kip’s parents for years and years for a long time. The things that the Night Gardener could have said was I will keep you forever
I think that the night man wrote the letter. It is only because i think he knows that they want to leave but he want to trick them.just because she said stay put I think we all know that’s him and they were going to leave but then now that kip and molly feel safe they’re not. It’s also important about the stay put thing because he gonna come for them. That’s the reasons why I think they are not safe.
I think the Night Gardener somehow knows Molly and Kips Ma´s hand writing. So I think The Night Gardener wrote the letter to Molly and Kip. Something strange they wrote was ´´STAY PUT NO MATTER WHAT´´. I think that is a little weird. It also says we escaped the snowy north
If they did they would be dead because of hypothermia. So we need to find more clues in the book.
I think Penny because it states in the book Penny doesn't want Molly and Kip to leave.Also because Penny really likes fairy tales so I think that Penny made that letter up to make sure they don't leave!
The part i am suspicious of is the part when the letter says “We’ll write again soon so stay put”. This is very odd to me so i think that it’s not Molly and Kips parents because they wouldn’t say to stay put they would probably say (don’t worry just go back home and we”ll meet you there ) but instead they told them to stay put and they will keep writing so i have an inference that it’s the night gardener because it came from that same tree he waters every night .
I think that the note is from the Night Gardener. I think this because I don't really think there parents would survive in the arctic for that long. I think the Night Gardener took their parents and he made Molly and Kips Ma write the letter.
The night gardener
I think the whole letter is a fake. I think that because of the way it came. A normal letters come in the mail but, this letter came from a knot in a tree. I think that the letter was wrote by The night man. I think this because the letter came from the house and in the beginning of the book it said that they were orphans and never met their parents. So how would they now can they say that the letter was written by ma and da. And the night man probably wants them to stay so he sent them this letter to make them feel safe and at home. I think that because they had seen him and have been in every room in this house so he does not want them to go around town telling people that the windows have a tree that has weapons stuck in it . And that the tree is protected by a man that comes out at night. I think that the last sentence is important to the book. I think that because the parents seem nice. And stay put no matter what dose not seem like something a parent that has not seen their kids in years would write. And how would the parents know where to find molly and kip. That has to have something to do with the night man and why he would do something like that to them does he want them to stay because they are scared and they had seen him that night when the were finding their horse. And the letter leads me to a few questions 1. Why would the family like the tree are they under a spell. 2. Why would the parents rely on the tree for money. Last question is why would penney have a books named after her. One even had molly and kip in it.
I think that the night man wrote the letter. I think the night man lives in the tree so he wrote the letter. He might have the same handwriting as their parents . In the beginning of the letter it says we received your letter. Molly didn’t send the letter? How just How?
This is just a question box if anyone has any idea's to how this works then you can comment! Question number 1: How would the parents know Molly and Kip were getting the letters? 2: How would the parents have survived in the arctic without heavy coats? 3: How would the parents have paper, pencils, sharpeners, and bottles? 4: How would the parents know were to send the letter? And 5: If it really was the parents and they knew were to send the letter, why now instead of the first second or third day?